Over the years, India’s financial sector has witnessed several high-profile scams where top executives and companies manipulated accounts and misused funds, leaving millions of investors in shock. But how could they pull this off? The answer often lies in clever accounting tricks and financial misstatements that go unnoticed until it is too late. So, the obvious question here is, how to detect and prevent such cases and what you, as an investor, can do? Dive into this blog to get answers to these questions and more on accounting manipulation and financial fraud, and enhance your understanding of corporate data.
Let us start with the basics, i.e., the meaning of financial fraud and accounting manipulation.
Financial fraud refers to any act of deception related to money, where someone cheats individuals, companies, or the government to gain unlawful financial benefits. In simple terms, it means lying or hiding the truth about money matters to make a profit or avoid losses.
We have seen many cases where companies took money from investors or banks and then misused it or never returned it. Sometimes, company owners create fake documents, overstate their business income, or even transfer company funds into personal accounts. These are all examples of financial fraud. For example, if a company borrows crores of rupees from banks, claiming it will use the money for business expansion, but instead uses it to buy luxury properties abroad, that constitutes financial fraud. It is not just illegal but also destroys trust in the financial systems and harms ordinary people who invest their hard-earned money in such companies.
Accounting manipulation is when a company intentionally changes or hides financial information in its books to show a better picture than reality. It is popularly known as window dressing, where the accounting books and, thereby, the company’s financial statements are made to look more successful than they actually are. This is often done to attract more investors, borrow more money from banks, increase share prices, or get management bonuses. Common tricks include inflating profits, hiding losses, underreporting expenses, or showing fake sales.
Consider a company making Rs. 10 crore in profit but wants to impress shareholders. So, it shows Rs. 20 crore in its financial report by tweaking numbers or adding fake income. This gives a false sense of growth, and investors may invest more, not knowing they are being misled.
While accounting manipulation may not always be as openly criminal as financial fraud, it is still unethical, dangerous, and can lead to major losses when the truth comes out.
Financial fraud or accounting manipulation amounts to a few tricks or practices that can lead to misstatements in the financial statements. Some examples or cases of financial fraud and accounting manipulation in financial statements include,
In this method, companies try to hide or reduce the costs they have to show more profit. Expenses like salaries, maintenance, or interest on loans may be either completely left out or delayed to a future period. Some companies also hide their debts or pending payments to make their balance sheet look stronger than it is. This can mislead banks and investors into thinking the company is financially healthy when it actually is not.
This is one of the most common tricks. Companies sometimes report income they have not actually earned yet, or create fake sales to make it look like their business is growing. This is done to attract more investors or borrow larger loans. For example, a company may say it sold goods worth Rs. 50 crore when in reality, it only sold Rs. 30 crore, or it may record income from a deal that has not even happened. This gives a false image of high performance.
This is a straightforward form of financial fraud where the company’s money or property is used for personal gain by its directors or employees. For instance, company funds may be used to buy private property, fund luxury travel, or invest in unrelated businesses, all without approval. Many large scams (like the Vijay Mallya and Nirav Modi cases) involved the misuse of funds taken from banks or investors.
Companies often do business with people or firms they are secretly connected to (like family members or personal firms of directors). These are called related party transactions. If not properly declared, such deals can be used to transfer money unfairly, inflate costs, or hide losses. SEBI require companies to report these clearly, however, frauds occur when such transactions are hidden or manipulated.
Another form of fraud is showing assets that do not exist or are overvalued. For example, companies may report having land, machinery, or inventory worth much more than their real value, or even list assets they do not own at all. This creates a false impression of wealth and stability. When reality comes out, it can lead to the sudden collapse of the system.
Now that we have seen a few examples of what financial fraud or accounting manipulation seems like, let us now focus on the possible reasons that can lead to such acts. Some of the possible reasons for financial fraud and accounting manipulation in businesses are highlighted below.
To show more profits and look successful to attract more investors.
To get bigger bank loans by faking strong financials to convince banks to lend more money.
To increase share prices and benefit owners.
To meet targets and get bonuses, some managers may fake numbers to get rewards or promotions.
To hide losses or poor performance to avoid loss of shareholders or directors’ trust.
To pay less tax by showing fake expenses or a low income to avoid paying taxes.
To misuse public or company money by taking funds from the company for personal use.
Weak internal controls and no proper checks or audits make it easier to cheat.
Low fear of punishment.
Greed and lack of ethics.
A financial statement, prima facie, may look to be correct and may seem to show the true and fair picture of an organisation. However, it may not be entirely true. So, are there any red flags to watch out for? Here is a brief list of a few examples of red flags that may indicate possible financial fraud and accounting manipulation.
Complicated or Unclear Financial Statements - When financial reports are too complex or hard to understand, it could be on purpose, i.e., to confuse investors and hide fraud. A good company should provide clear and simple statements.
Unusually High Profits Every Year - If a company keeps showing very high profits every year, even when the industry is struggling, it could be a warning sign. No business performs perfectly all the time. Consistently high profits may be fake or inflated to impress investors and banks.
Frequent Changes in Accounting Policies - If a company keeps changing the way it reports its income, expenses, or assets, it could be trying to hide something. Frequent changes in accounting methods are a classic trick used to manipulate results.
Mismatch Between Cash Flow and Profit - If a company is showing big profits but its cash flow (actual money coming in) is very low, something is wrong. Profits on paper should match real money in the bank over time. If not, the numbers could be manipulated.
Unusual Growth in Assets or Debts - If a company suddenly shows very high assets or takes on a lot of debt, without strong business reasons, it may be inflating its value or hiding financial trouble. Be cautious of such sudden changes.
Too Many Related Party Transactions - When a company does a lot of business with people or firms connected to its promoters or directors, and does not explain them well, it raises concerns. These deals can be used to divert money or create fake income.
Auditor Resignation or Change - If a company frequently changes its auditors or if an auditor resigns suddenly, it could be because they discovered something suspicious. This is a major red flag that should not be ignored.
Delay in Financial Reporting - If a company keeps delaying the release of its financial statements, it might be hiding losses or struggling to fix errors. Timely reporting is a sign of transparency.
Understanding accounting manipulation and financial fraud is one thing, but the key question is how to detect it and prevent it from happening. While there are many checks and measures put in place to ensure the integrity of financial statements, here are a few pointers to detect and prevent financial fraud and accounting manipulation in financial statements.
Read Financial Statements Carefully - Always check the company's financial reports (like balance sheet, profit & loss statement, and cash flow statement). Look for anything unusual, like sudden spikes in profit, low cash flow, or confusing numbers, as these could be signs of manipulation.
Focus on Cash Flow, Not Just Profits - Profits can be faked, but cash is harder to manipulate. Always check if the company is actually generating real cash. If a company shows high profits but low or negative cash flow, that is a warning sign.
Track Auditor Reports and Qualifications - Go through the auditor’s comments in the annual report. If the auditor has raised doubts or refused to give a clean report, take it seriously. Also, be cautious if the company changes auditors often, as it may be trying to hide fraud.
Compare with Past Performance and Industry - Compare the company’s current numbers with its past records and competitors. If its growth or profit seems too high or too smooth compared to others in the same industry, it may be using tricks to look better than it is.
Watch for Frequent Accounting Changes - If the company keeps changing its accounting methods or policies, it might be adjusting numbers to hide poor performance. Consistent policies mean transparency; too many changes mean something could be wrong.
Check Corporate Governance Practices - Good companies have independent directors, strong internal controls, and transparent policies. If a company is run mostly by family or close friends, with weak governance, it increases the chance of fraud.
Review Notes to Accounts and Footnotes - The ‘Notes to Accounts’ section in financial statements often contains hidden details, like pending legal cases, loans to relatives, or changes in accounting rules. Reading this section can uncover things the main report hides.
Monitor Sudden Rise in Stock Price - If a company’s stock price suddenly rises without any strong business reason, it could be due to artificial hype or insider manipulation. Always check if the rise is supported by real financial performance.
Stay Updated with News and Alerts - Follow reliable financial news, SEBI updates, and stock exchange announcements. Whistleblower reports, audits, or sudden resignations are early warning signs. Staying informed helps you react quickly.
Financial fraud and accounting manipulation can seriously harm investors, banks, and the economy. In India, we have seen many big scams that could have been avoided with better awareness and careful checks. Investors thus need to have a basic knowledge of reading financial statements and analysing them, along with staying alert to red flags.
This article talks about a key concept of understanding corporate data and financial statements and protecting investors’ funds. Let us know your thoughts on this topic or if you have any queries, and we will address them.
Till then, Happy Reading!
Marisha Bhatt is a financial content writer @TrueData.
She writes with the sole aim of simplifying complex financial concepts and jargon while attempting to clarify technical and fundamental analysis concepts of the stock markets. The ultimate goal is to spread vital knowledge and benefit the maximum audience. Her Chartered Accountant background acts as the knowledge base to help clarify crucial concepts and create a sound investment portfolio.
Thecompany’s financial statements are the starting point for evaluating it...
Thestock market never stands still, and prices swing constantly with every new h...
If you are a shareholder of a company, you would have seen its annual reports co...
